by Manzanita Miller
While we have been extensively reporting on former President Donald Trump’s significant increase in support compared to 2020 among working class voters, minorities, and young people, one group of Americans appears to be shifting away from Trump at the margins – seniors. Voters over age 65 have shown a shift away from Trump in recent polls that amounts to as much as ten percentage points compared to 2020.
Trump’s highest level of success in 2020 was among voters over 65, with the former President winning seniors by five points, 52 percent to 47 percent. However, several recent polls show Trump losing seniors to Biden by around ten points. The March New York Times/Siena College poll shows President Joe Biden leading with seniors 51 percent to 42 percent.
A new Marist poll shows Biden winning Boomers and Silent Generation voters by three and six points respectively after losing both to Trump in 2020. A recent Mainstreet Research poll shows Biden winning seniors by over ten points. Although as we recently noted, the same poll shows Biden losing voters under 35 by an eye-popping 16 points.
While the reasons for seniors shifting away from Trump are no doubt complex, there is evidence that factors such as Trump’s stance on Ukraine and concerns about democracy are contributing to the marginal shift. In addition, seniors see the economy as less bleak than younger voters do, and therefore have less immediate motivation to replace Biden.
It is worth noting the ten-point or so shift away from Trump among older voters is far smaller than the twenty-to-thirty-point shift away from Biden among young people and minorities. The shifts may be seen as more of a realignment within both parties. That said, seniors formed a key component of Trump’s base in both 2016 and 2020, and it is worth looking at the reasons they may be retracting their support.
First, seniors appear more concerned with the prospect of democracy being under threat, a key argument from the left since the 2020 election and throughout a series of legal issues that have plagued Former President Trump. Democrats have heavily pushed the narrative that democracy and by extension American life is “under threat” due to Trump’s actions and while most conservatives disagree, seniors tend to be the most concerned.
A Quinnipiac poll from August 2023 during a series of indictments against Trump, found that voters over 65 are significantly more worried about “the system of democracy being able to function”.
Over twice as many voters over 65 – 58 percent – said they were very worried about “the system of democracy” being threatened compared to just 26 percent of voters under 34. Forty-four percent of voters between 35 and 49 and 54 percent of voters 50 to 64 said they were very worried about democracy.
The latest New York Times/Siena poll also reveals seniors are around ten points more likely than middle-aged voters to believe Trump has committed serious crimes. Voters under thirty believe so at a higher rate than seniors do, however.
Trump’s stance on U.S. economic and military aid to Ukraine, another contentious issue, could be driving some older Trump supporters away. According to the same Quinnipiac poll, a greater share of older voters believe the U.S. is providing “the right” amount of aid to Ukraine compared to younger voters, a position held by many Democrats.
According to the poll, a full 49 percent of seniors – the largest share – thinks the U.S. is providing “the right” amount of aid to Ukraine. Far fewer – 29 percent – of voters under 35 agree. Among older Millennials and Gen X voters, around 38 percent believe the U.S. is providing “the right” amount of aid to Ukraine. What is clear is seniors are far more likely to agree with sustaining U.S. aid to Ukraine than younger generations.
In fact, comparing New York Times / Siena polling from last November to polling conducted in early March, a senior shift in favor of additional support for Ukraine appears to coincide with a shift away from Trump.
The November 2023 Times poll revealed seniors showing the highest level of support for additional aid to Ukraine, with 42 percent of seniors saying they “strongly support” such measures. In the same poll, Biden was beating Trump among senior voters by five percentage points – 48 percent to 43 percent – after losing seniors by five points in 2020. At the time, 9 percent of Americans were undecided.
Fast forward to the March 2024 Times poll, and not only has the share of seniors saying they strongly support upping U.S. aid to Ukraine increased by over ten percentage points, but Biden has gained with seniors. The latest Times poll shows 55 percent of seniors now say they strongly support upping aid to Ukraine, a thirteen-point increase from November. Biden’s support among seniors has risen to 51 percent, a three-point increase since November and a four-point increase since 2020. Trump’s support has dropped one point to 42 percent since November and a full ten points since 2020. The share of Americans saying they wouldn’t vote or would choose someone else has shrunk by two points to seven percent of the electorate since November.
It is worth adding that seniors side with Israel at a significantly higher rate than younger voters do as well – indicating support for maintaining U.S. involvement in the nation’s fight against Hamas is higher.
Lastly, while seniors have their own set of economic gripes, older voters are significantly more likely to see the economy as on an upward trajectory compared to younger voters. According to the Times/Siena poll, 40 percent of seniors compared to around a fifth or Gen X and Millennial voters and a quarter of Gen Z voters see the economy as improved compared to last year. While younger voters are struggling to increase their wages and acquire assets in the stock and housing markets, seniors on average own more assets with which to battle inflation.
The bottom line is that while older voters have been core Trump supporters since the beginning – and many still are – seniors align more with Trump on his original goals like solving the border crisis and restructuring trade than they do on foreign policy. A portion of seniors are more concerned about the future of democracy compared to younger voters, and older voters see the economy as improving at a higher rate, reducing immediate incentives to replace Biden.
As Trump has widened his support among historically left-wing groups including young people and minorities through his focus on non-interventionism and the economy, he may be losing support among more hawkish seniors. Whether he can correct course and court seniors back is yet to be determined but focusing on immigration – an issue seniors largely back him on – would be a good focal point.
– – –
Manzanita Miller is an associate analyst at Americans for Limited Government Foundation.
Image “Donald Trump” by Dan Scavino Jr.
